Sarah's Question

by C.J. Couvillion
(Baton Rouge, LA)

Sarah's Question was written around 9/1/10. It is the first chapter of my book called, "Nightmare to Normal."
Here are a few paragraphs from that piece.

My son, Stephen, collapsed from accidental drug intoxication in his apartment in Philadelphia on April 23, 2010, while a graduate student at Temple University. He was rushed to St. Joseph’s Hospital, where he was put on life support and was pronounced dead at approximately 6 a.m. on April 25, 2010. It was a Sunday morning. My wife Kathy and I and our friend Kevin were on our way to Philly from New Orleans, in the process of boarding the plane when we heard the sad news. We arrived that Sunday afternoon at 4 p.m. at the hospital, where we were escorted to the morgue to view his body. It was a devastating experience.

The day he collapsed was a blur and a nightmare, filled with what seemed an endless string of stressful phone calls to the hospital in Philly, to friends and relatives, and to make hotel and airline reservations. And, in addition, there was this brief conversation between Sarah, Stephen’s sister and my daughter, and I which went something like this. “Dad,” asked Sarah, “do you think Stephen is in hell?” I don’t remember what I said. But, I do remember just staring at her for a minute, to gather my rambling thoughts, as I watched her cry and sob her eyes out.

That conversation with Sarah happened on April 23rd. It is now, at this writing, September 1st, and I am still thinking about her question. How do you answer that kind of a question? There is the Sunday school answer from Mark 16:16 of “he who believes and is baptized will be saved.” There is the “tell-me-what-I-want-to-hear” answer of “God is a God of love and mercy. He would never send anyone to hell.” There is the “I-haven’t-really-studied-it-yet” answer of “there is no hell.” And, there is the honest “I don’t know.” I think that in this particular instance, sometime later, I eventually landed on “I don’t know.” But, I could not say with any certainty why I landed there, and I did not tell that to Sarah.

“Dad, do you think Stephen is in hell?” “No. I don’t.” is now my answer. Stephen was baptized into the faith and received the Holy Spirit. We received a letter from the pastor who baptized him recently, Alvin Epperson, who tried to reassure us of that very fact. In addition, Stephen had made a profession of faith at a fairly young age. He was washed in the blood of the Lamb and his sins were forgiven.

Life is difficult. I have purposely packed this writing with numerous quotes from various figures, Christian and non-Christian, to make that point. Stephen’s life was very hard and very messy and filled with pain, a struggle all the way, and a search for its meaning. His struggle and lifestyle were impossible to ignore and to some, it was all they could see in him. In the end, though he did not give up on life, but unfortunately he entered a path which eventually took his life. But those who knew him best knew that he had the identifying mark of the Christian. He never lost the love of Jesus in his heart for his family and for others in his life. His very long struggle is over and he is finally at rest.

Comments for Sarah's Question

Click here to add your own comments

May 16, 2013
Hope for Abby
by: Ann

My daughter died in a car accident and while she did the same things that your son did, the confession of sin and need of salvationa & water baptism. My thoughts have been all over the place, she was a complicated person, part obedient and loving child and young woman and a part of her that she had a difficult time controlling.The parties and friendship with people who were not living a christian life and most likely never experienced that life. She loved attention and the wrong kind of attention. I remember telling her how worried I was for her she had a series of small accidents and made some bad decisions in the months before she died.She would acknowlege that she needed to settle down her behavior and always reassured me that she was "OK". I trust that she is in heaven with Jesus and I find the thoughts of uncertainty that I so often feel as a weapon of satan to cause me to not heal. My heart is still heavy with the grief of our loss. But trusting Jesus is my only comfort and I hope I will be able to post at some time that I am breathing and smiling from a heart of peace.

Dec 16, 2011
important question
by: Janelle


Thanks for sharing this reflection. I found that grief also caused me to ask some spiritual questions that I wouldn't have asked previously.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Loss of a Child-CJ.

Enjoy this page? Please pay it forward. Here's how...

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it?

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.